Friday, August 20, 2010

Term 3 Week 8 Assembly

Term 3 Week 8 Assembly

Recently, during our level assembly, there had been a speech by a SBS Transit staff on traffic safety. The speaker had made many grammatical errors and said many things wrongly. The students are to be blamed for being ill-behaved, however, I think that there are always two sides to a coin.

The students are at fault for laughing at the speaker. Because of one minor mistake, the students had continually laughed and laughed, at every mistake the speaker made they laughed at her in a mocking manner. This would have caused the speaker to have felt very offended. The students could have laughed since the first mistake was especially hilarious (A bus cost $380 million). However because of this one mistake the students thought of her as a lousy speaker and thus she might have been pressured to not make any mistakes and try to make amendments to her mistake, causing a lot of pressure on her, resulting in even more mistakes.

Students are representative of Hwa Chong and should always upkeep the image of our school always, especially in the presence of visitors or external visitors. The students should have instead thought of the first mistake that this was just a normal speech with normal mistakes, thus accepting it instead of mocking would have been a much better idea.

The students also thought that these slides were totally redundant since we already know the safety rules and regulations. This presentation was extremely redundant. Since it was not useful to students, they might as well get some fun out of it, thus mocking the speaker. This is the wrong type of attitude to have. The level assembly is a formal event and students should always observe proper decorum and thus maintaining the image of our school. Even if the presentation was totally useless (Which it nearly was?), we should at least act like we were listening and we had not heard of these rules.

However, the speaker did have her own faults. The Power Point presentation was substandard. There were grammatical errors throughout the slides (e.g. Caning became canning). She had not checked her slides before, nor put in more effort to ensure that there were no grammatical errors in her presentation.

She was not well prepared. She had come unprepared and pronounced many things wrongly. Hwa Chong students are normally skeptical about other’s mistakes. This cannot be blamed on the students. The students are groomed in an extremely competitive environment where they are always competing to see who the best is. Thus, the moment another person makes a mistake, we will not hesitate to step on him/her and make him/her feel that she has made a grave mistake although she only made a small mistake. This is not totally the student’s fault since all elite schools have competitive environments. But the students should understand that this was an external speaker and not one of our teachers.

What I have said here though is extremely contradictive to what I did on the day itself, I was on of those that laughed the loudest and probably getting a few more people to laugh with me. I know that I was wrong since we should not expect the kind of standards we would receive from Hwa Chong students. Thus I will not make a conclusion on this incident since I am a student myself and will be partial. But students must always observe proper decorum in formal events such as the level assembly. But the mistakes were simply too funny.(I personally think I would have laughed till my stomach hurt if the teachers were not around). But I think that we should always maintain our school’s image regardless of the situation.

Villanelle ACE

Unity in division


Divided we stood, United we stand

In the face of these fearsome monsters

Brothers bonded as one soul


Piles of homework creating mountains on our desks

Cursing and swearing as the teacher leaves the class

Divided we stood, United we stand


The exam period has arrived

Joy or misery, we cry it out together

Brothers bonded as one soul

Virtual soccer played by two brothers

All watch. All get caught

Divided we stood, United we stand


Streaming results are coming soon

We treasure our relationships more than ever

Brothers bonded as one soul


Streaming results released:

Brothers separated physically, never mentally

Divided we stood, United we stand

Brothers bonded as one soul

Independent studies and Oral Communication

OC and IS

This is one of the most absurd things I have ever heard of. Projects day used to something extra, something to get you some extra ACE points so that you need not do all the last minute ACE projects. But this year, projects day is counted into our scholastic MSG. This might be okay if the groups were all judged equally. I feel that having so many different categories and every category has its own passing rate. Some of these rates are extra high in certain categories, some even 100% pass rate for Secondary 2s), while in other categories pass rates are extremely low.

There is obviously a problem with the Independent studies module, how a graded subject be so unfair. Some categories are just so easy to pass yet others are just plain killers. The projects day competition must always have the same judging criteria and all should have about the same pass rate. When there is so much deviation between the categories, some students will fail very badly while others pass with flying colors. There must be some form of common judging such that there is not category that is too hard or too easy. For examples, there should be the same rubrics or have the same judges to judge everyone. Where this is not possible, projects should not be counted into our MSG.

Worse still, this affects our promotion. What kind of absurd thinking is this? How can something so unfair still take up 50% of a subject and the promotion criteria is 65%. Many people will fail the criteria and end up in the 3Q class. This decreases the overall attitude of the student body toward the school.

Also, another module added this year is the Oral Communications. The oral communications module consists of a current affairs discussion and a interview in both languages, English and Chinese. However, in the past, CA discussion was also something extra to help you earn some extra Oral Participations points so that you will not have to dry out your saliva trying to get the 10 OP marks. However, nowadays, even though the CA discussions are counted into our MSG too, there are still student judges. Of course there are impartial judges, but there will always does who become judges so as to sabotage one of the panelists. In classes, there is a bound to be clash of interests. This results in many friends and enemies being made. In the CA discussion, a judge would give his buddy a much higher mark than he actually deserves. Also, enemies will give a much a lower mark than deserved. Although the teacher has the final say in who gets what marks, but the kind of marks and comments that the judge gives will still affect the teacher thus a student will get a mark he doesn’t deserve if the student judge is partial.

Thus I think that these two modules have major problems. Even though they have been changed to become a new subject itself, the unfairness has not been removed. Last time, when we got low marks for projects day or CA discussion we would just let it pass as there is always a second chance. But now its counted into the MSG and still as unfair as before. I think these two modules should not have been implemented in the first place. If the school wants to implement these two modules then they should have change it such that everyone is graded based on ability, not relations or choice of category. However, it is too late to do anything as this module is nearing completion.

Touch hearts forging bonds

This is the name of Max’s Service learning project. This project aims to aid Muslim students in subjects they were weak in. I heard of this project and decided that this was a good CIP opportunity and asked max whether I could go help out. Then I started my first session. The first session was a disaster, it was the day Orchard Road flooded, trains were delayed(I don’t know how since I was take in the East-West line), but I arrived at the mosque late.

There, I had to mark the scripts of these Muslim students. First was Math, I could not believe how low their level was. Simple equations that I had become so familiar that I could answer without using my brain, was so hard they needed 10 minutes to think before giving a answer. I was horrified. Luckily, I only marked a few scripts, if I had marked anymore I would have coughed blood. The biggest problem was that they did not ever think about improving themselves at all, all they wanted was to go for the tuition and have fun. Then, my though was “If they don’t want to help themselves, why should we help them.” The experience was so horrendous that I did not want to come for the project again. And at the end of my first session, I went home with a black toes thanks to the Malays boys who played rough during soccer.

The second session I had was considerably better since nearly the whole team was there and there were more Malay kids. Unlike the last time, this time we really had to teach them something and not just give them a test a mark it. We did a simple topic of speed. I though “C’mon Max, you don’t really expect us to teach them something as simple as that?” In the end, while we were explaining to them what speed was, we ended up joking and making a fool of ourselves. Max scolded me “You don’t understand the true meaning of CIP. Do you know what this is for?”. I didn’t understand him at first. But after that after pondering over what he said, those kids may not want to help themselves but as a volunteer we still have the responsibility to ensure that they understand what we were saying, or at least try and understand.

The third session was also the last session for this year. I brought my computer I try and make PowerPoint slides so that we would not have to go through the trouble of using the traditional white board. But in the end, the only room in the mosque which had a projector was occupied and we had to move to a much smaller room and squeeze there. In the end, I ended up playing Modern Warfare 2 since the lesson became so boring. This lesson was the one that had me the most angry. While we were explaining the mistakes to them, we explained everything to them and they said they understood, but they got the question wrong again after that. How could they have understood? Then I realized what Max was talking about, these kids were smart, they just needed some motivation, some force to push them forward and they would go a long way. No kid is really stupid, its only how much effort they want to put it, but we are just helping them put in that effort. And we were that force, I failed to realize it until the very end. My aim in coming was not to teach them, but motivate them, teaching was just a secondary objective.

That was the last time I visited that mosque. They had planned one more session with the mosque but was cancelled in view of out End Of Year examinations. These children were clever but lacked the motivation. Max wanted to leave the project where it was but I have promised him that I would take over it next year. Hopefully, I will do a good job next year and not get so obsessed with CIP that I forget the real meaning why I was there. This was a good lesson learnt.